BudgetAutoRates affordability gauge: New York premiums vs state median income. Local claim costs and pricing pressure keep the needle out of the green.
| Company | Liability / mo | Full coverage / mo | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| State Farm | $58 | $140 | Overall cheapest |
| GEICO | $63 | $154 | Digital-first drivers |
| Progressive | $73 | $179 | High-risk / SR-22 |
| Allstate | $86 | $208 | Bundling home + auto |
| Farmers | $93 | $226 | Agent relationships |
| Liberty Mutual | $101 | $246 | Custom coverage add-ons |
Illustrative estimates for layout and comparison purposes; see our methodology.
New York requires liability coverage on every registered vehicle. The legal floor:
Minimum coverage keeps you legal, not necessarily solvent: the average new truck costs more than $10,000 to replace, so one at-fault accident can outrun your property-damage limit.
No-fault state: $50k PIP and UM required; 50/100 BI applies to death claims.
Minimums cross-checked against Insurance Information Institute and state DOI sources, July 2026; see our methodology. Rules change; verify current minimums with your state's Department of Insurance.
Premiums swing inside New York: traffic density, claim frequency, and repair costs vary from ZIP to ZIP, so quote with your exact address.
Rates in New York run about 13% above the national average, at about $93/mo for liability and $226/mo for full coverage. Traffic density, weather claims, repair costs, and uninsured drivers all feed into local pricing, and comparing 3 or more quotes is the fastest way to come in under the state average.
Penny asks:"What does skipping coverage really cost in New York?" Scout answers:"Fines, license suspension, SR-22 filings, and reinstatement fees, with exact amounts set by state law. A minimum policy is cheaper than the paperwork. Verify penalties with the New York Department of Insurance."
BudgetAutoRates